Case study: materials testing

Improving lab training and student engagement through VR

Objective

Reduce student errors and safety risks, increase student engagement, and improve learning outcomes.

Want results like these in your program? See how department chairs launch virtual labs for higher education.

Materials testing in VR

Overview

VR lab training for a materials testing course

This VR lab training project set out to improve lab training while reducing the overall cost and safety risks for students in mechanical engineering laboratory classes. HyperSkill was used to show that non-programmers can create high quality VR based training simulations.

See how schools use it across subjects in VR in education.

Features of the virtual lab

Immersive experience

Students run the tensile test in a virtual lab built for engagement and experiential learning.

Incorporating physics of material behavior

Specimen deformation and stresses come from finite element analysis (FEA), so students see the physics of the test.

Conversational AI

Students ask the simulation questions as they work through the lab.

Challenges with conventional methods

Student errors can damage expensive machines, resulting in tens of thousands of dollars in repair costs as well as significant downtime and lab scheduling disruptions.

The tension test was selected because of the high equipment cost and the safety risks inherent in high tension material testing. Faculty at Texas A&M University (TAMU) were looking for ways to improve lab training while reducing the overall cost and safety risks. The requirements were specific:

Eliminate the safety risks, equipment availability bottlenecks and costly damage risks

Increase student engagement

Improve learning outcomes

Solution

SimInsights teamed up with TAMU and Instron and began work on three fronts.

An immersive approach to virtual labs

With an emphasis on engagement and experiential learning.

Randomized controlled trial (RCT) based evaluation

To rigorously assess the impact of interventions in human subject studies.

Innovative authoring software for immersive training

Called HyperSkill, to enable faculty and other subject matter experts to create their own immersive content.

Design of the simulation and the study

HyperSkill was used to create most of the tensile test simulation, except the specimen deformation and stresses, which were computed using Abaqus finite element analysis (FEA) simulation software from Dassault Systèmes and imported into HyperSkill. Pilot testing was conducted at Texas A&M University.

118

Students in a two-group randomized controlled trial, run as part of a course

57

In the control condition: the Instron machine first, followed by VR

61

In the experimental condition: VR first, then the Instron machine

Results of the pilot test suggested an overall positive outcome for students who did the VR virtual lab first (experimental condition) compared to those who did the physical lab first (control condition).

Delivery

SimInsights VR system integration

Three VR systems were set up in a separate room in the engineering building. Instructors from different classes could reserve the room for their students. Students could access the room at their own convenience, log in and experience the VR simulations as many times as needed. The data could be collected and shared with the relevant instructors.

Courses using the VR room

Besides the initial materials course, additional faculty have used the setup for their courses.

Materials

Industrial Engineering

Chemical Engineering

Engineering Design

Materials Testing lab in VR
Materials testing lab in VR

Measurable benefits

Analysis of pilot test data (survey measures, action and sensor data) from 118 students revealed these highlights.

Free response questions (FR)

106%

Greater learning gains on free response questions

Analysis of pre-post gains showed significantly higher gains for participants in the VR activity than for those in the Instron activity.

Evaluating the impact

23%

Greater learning gains on multiple choice questions (MCQ)

Students who did the VR activity first scored 23% higher on MCQ subject matter scores, including 5% higher procedural subscale and 49% higher conceptual subscale scores.

100%

Greater engagement

Students reported significantly higher engagement after the VR activity than after the physical lab.

100%

Greater learning gains for female participants

Subgroup analysis of pre-post learning gains showed that females in the experimental group gained twice as much as males.

Success factors

Four key factors contributed to the success of the project.

1

Content first

SimInsights matched the realism of the interactions and exceeded the richness of the learning by using nonlinear finite element analysis (FEA) simulation to visualize the physics of material testing.

2

Data driven

Starting with the early usability studies conducted with TAMU students, SimInsights followed the data to drive prioritization and design of the software features and functionality.

3

Conversational AI

Conversational AI has always been a key element of our VR experience design strategy. Students loved it from the very beginning, gave valuable feedback that drove refinements, and challenged the team to support increasingly complex and meaningful queries.

4

Partnering with the experts

The most important success factor was partnering with experts early on, with weekly meetings with key faculty and even teaching assistants. This let our team produce content that addressed key learning and assessment objectives.

What faculty and partners say

“I have been using the HyperSkill CNC machining simulation in my courses in Industrial Engineering at Texas A&M for the last couple of years. It is both an engaging experience for students and offers substantial educational value for the targeted content. Furthermore, the VR simulation is a nice tool to get students thinking about innovative applications of this exciting technology in other domains.”

Dinakar S.

Dinakar S.

Assistant Professor, Industrial Engineering, Texas A&M University

“I have been developing a chemical plant control VR simulation for use in my courses in Chemical Engineering at Texas A&M, and it has been a pleasure to work with the SimInsights team and their software platform. VR has tremendous potential for the future of education.”

Joseph Kwon

Joseph Kwon

Assistant Professor, Chemical Engineering, Texas A&M University

“Our faculty have been developing VR and AR content for use in our mechanical engineering courses at Michigan Tech, and it has been a pleasure to work with the SimInsights team and their software platform. VR/AR technology has tremendous potential for the future of education and research.”

William Predebon

William Predebon

Professor and J. S. Endowed Chair of Mechanical Engineering-Engineering Mechanics, Michigan Technological University

“It was my pleasure to support this project by SimInsights from the Instron side. We provided CAD models and technical information, which enabled SimInsights to create a realistic virtual simulation of the Instron machines. Later the team visited our headquarters in Massachusetts to demonstrate their solutions. This technology has a promising future for training and sales purposes.”

Britt Smallwood

Britt Smallwood

Business Unit Manager, High Force Applications, Instron

Read the full case study

Download the case study as a PDF, or ask us for a demo of VR lab training for your own courses.

Scroll to Top